Hunchback of the Morgue

I must admit to not being terribly au fait with the Spanish horror industry that sprang up around the same time as the Italian one in the 1960s beyond a couple of obvious names like Jess Franco and Paul Naschy, but it appears to have been as OK with actual animal cruelty as its Italian counterpart would be… yuck. I mean, I’m not a megafan of rats either, but still…

Anyway, around 15 years ago I saw my first Paul Naschy film, The Werewolf vs. The Vampire Woman; it was a barely watchable probable bootleg, but beneath the shitty video quality I could sense something of interest. I meant to explore Naschy further, but haven’t done so until now. It was Youtube’s resident Naschy enthusiast Daniel at The Cobwebs Channel who finally convinced me to invest in the Scream Factory collections of his work, and I chose this particular title because I found this terrific essay on it (thank you again, Substack), which I think is quite correct in finding the animal cruelty abhorrent but also in identifying what makes it work otherwise, a substantial part of which is Naschy himself.

This is one of his non-Waldemar Daninsky films, in which he is the titular hunchback, Gotho, but he’s not the monster of the movie. Granted, he kills multiple people through the film, and in remarkably gory fashion for a film made at that time too; but Gotho is a hunchback far more sinned against than sinning, a figure of freakish fun to his fellow townsfolk but essentially kind and loving until provoked. He is the film’s sorely-beset focus of sympathy. When the young woman he loves dies, he encounters the real monster of the movie, Dr. Orla, who makes use of him for his, er, unorthodox experiments. All of this is told in a way that could be described as “jagged”, full of abrupt scene cuts and transitions; it’s somewhat unbalanced and not entirely coherent, but it captures a suitably grim mood (even if the apparently night-time exteriors are kind of suspiciously well-“lit”). I enjoyed this, it basically gave me what I’d hoped for from it. I just wish it hadn’t also given me those burning rats…